🔥 Gas Furnace vs Heat Pump Cost: Complete 2025 Comparison
Gas Furnace: Lower upfront cost ($3,800-$12,000), reliable in extreme cold, but only heats (no cooling).
Heat Pump: Higher upfront cost ($6,000-$15,000), but 3-4x more efficient and provides both heating AND cooling. Best for moderate climates.
Bottom Line: Choose a heat pump if you need A/C too, want lower operating costs, and live where winters stay above 0°F. Choose gas if you have very cheap natural gas or extreme cold.
🎯 Quick Decision Matrix
🔥 Choose Gas Furnace If:
- Natural gas is cheap in your area (<$1/therm)
- Winters drop below -15°F regularly
- You already have a separate A/C system
- Upfront cost is your top priority
- Your existing ductwork is gas-optimized
❄️ Choose Heat Pump If:
- You need heating AND cooling (2-in-1)
- Electricity rates are reasonable in your area
- You want lowest operating costs long-term
- You want to reduce carbon footprint
- Your climate has mild winters (above 0°F)
- Your A/C is due for replacement anyway
📊 Detailed Comparison (2025 Data)
* Costs are US national averages for 2024-2025. Actual costs vary by location, home size, and installer. Sources: HomeGuide, Carrier, Energy.gov, Modernize.
🏆 Best of Both: Dual-Fuel System
The dual-fuel system combines a heat pump with a gas furnace backup. The heat pump handles mild weather (above 35-40°F) at high efficiency. The gas furnace kicks in during extreme cold.
- Optimal efficiency: Uses the most efficient system for each temperature range
- Cost: $10,000-$20,000 installed (more than either alone)
- Best for: Cold climates (Northeast, Midwest) where temps drop below 0°F
- Savings: Can reduce heating costs by 30-50% vs gas-only systems
Calculate Your Savings
Get a personalized estimate based on your location, energy rates, and home size.
Use Free Calculator →